Thana,
If the truth (good or bad) for one doctor can not be discussed than how can we trust that anything else posted regarding that doctor is the truth? I feel all the forbidden topics already hurt one board dramatically. I really do not think we should follow that path. I'm not one of those posters that likes fighting nor flame wars but I do value the truth greatly. I think hiding the truth (good or bad) can lead to many really disappointed patients who feel misled and cheated.
"The truth shall set you free" is a pretty good saying.