I personally don't have a problem with someone being outspoken about a doctor they feel doesn't qualify as a top surgeon in hair restoration. It's subjective, but it's hard to find negative reviews of top HT surgeons and any criticism should give anyone considering something as serious as hair transplantation pause before they either take the plunge or choose a surgeon. It's a major decision.
If those negative comments compel you to do more research about a doctor it can only be a good thing. If they steer you in another direction, that's part of the research process. I imagine there are countless members here (like myself) who were pretty sure who they were going to for their procedure, only to see a comment or read a review that made them keep searching. I don't think there's such thing as over-thinking, over-researching or waiting too long when it comes to hair restoration.
This idea of 'it's easily remedied' galls me. Yes, hair restoration has a lot of variables, but there are too many consistently good surgeons out there for that to be a fall back position anymore. As far as I'm concerned, you don't get too many chances of sub-optimal work if you want to be considered the best in any field. Just my two cents.
I hope it all turns out satisfactory for you asiandude.