I agree with J.A.C - this seems to stem from the Arshad threads. It's quite concerning that he has had two pretty poor results in short order with no real explanation why. This forum is great because it has real results from real people, so you can get actual proper advice on who a good surgeon is and what kind of results to expect.
However, a doctor is only as good as his last transplant, and if he has more than one bad result recently, this should call his credibility into question. Users should also be able to point this out without being vilified.
As we have seen with the Covid BS of the last two years, the more you censor differing opinions, the more people stop trusting what you say.
Let's keep this an open and honest forum where everybody can say what they feel, as long as they are being respectful. If a surgeon is producing bad results, I want to know about it before I decide to book with that person.