I'm in the same boat as you Mick...I have had different opinions in terms of graft size...I am a Norwood 3...1 doc said around 1,200 to 1,700, another about 1,700 and the last one said approx. 2,500. The 1,700 docs said you will prob have to come back for density while the 2,500 doc said one pass and you will enjoy the density. I also am struggling with the usual FUT vs. FUE. I don't want the scar as all my life I have always worn my donor hair at a 2 to 3 clip so I don't feel comfortable having the "smiley face" scar shine through bc i don't have great coverage with a 2 or 3 clip. But of course there are limitations with FUE in the potential yield so I think to myself that is it worth having less yield and no scar or a scar and higher yield? Because I also understand that any second procedure can be rough on the donor area...FUE or FUT...you are dealing with scar tissue at this point and I could only imagine your scalp can have so much laxity as it may tighten up...FUE on the other hand has tiny little scar tissue all throughout the donor area and could like someone said above cause the donor area to thin out if you take too many grafts...ahhh...decisions decisions...lol. I think at the end of the day I am going to go with the FUE bc of the scar issue and also I feel pretty comfortable with the doctor and he has good bedside manner that if anything went wrong he would correct it...that is important too.