Bill,
I must admire your fairness in this matter. I would be surprised if Dr. Umar would be interested in participating in this kind of discussion given the atmosphere in the forum. I am sure running a one Dr. clinic, plus his participation in endless research towards the betterment of all facets of FUE HT work keep him more than busy. The presentation of his work at the convention before all of his peers speaks volumes as to why, according to your own words, "he is arguably one the leading BHT doctors".
As for statements made by roscoepoce, his statement assume that Dr. Umar will take any BHT patient that comes along. This assumption is patently false. Some of you are also members of HLH. Look up the threads started by a angry ORP967 (a few months ago). This patient was very upset because Dr. Umar turned him down as a viable BHT patient. ORP967 posted his discontent on several threads all over HLH. He also tried to smear the docs clinic by stating they never return email or calls. What? Anyone who has personally dealt with Dr. Umar's clinic knows this is just another falsehood. Granted, since Dr. Umar answers all of his own email, it may take him a couple of days to get back to a patient.
That is all I had to say. I am not a paid consulant, just a guy who dreamed about an HT for over 15 years. Thanks to forums like these, I came across a good doc. I am happy with my results. For years I though HT must be a myth, because if not, why didn't more bald guys get HT's? I was pleasantly surprised to find out FUE/HT is not a myth, and really can be good in the right hands.
You all have a good day,
Atticus