Beaverbuzz (interesting nick ), in my opinion, this design is extremely poor. Looking at your pre-surgery photos (both buzzed and grown out), you only needed some temple work. The "temple points" should have been left alone. As another poster mentioned, it has elongated your face making your recession look worse. Although it does look like you have a lack of growth, I don't think that is the main issue here.
I would recommend getting a second opinion from another physician. Take your pick on this forum...
Just my 2 cents. I wish you the best of luck.