I am looking for advice from the forum on how to resolve my terrible pluggy appearance (2 sessions from the mid 90s) and frontal hair loss. The two Coalition doctors from my area I have consulted with in person have recommended polar opposite approaches:
1) linear excision of row of plugs along hairline + 2000 grafts over 2 sessions
OR
2) camouflage in front, in between and behind existing plugs with 1,000-1,200 grafts
One doctor is convinced the camouflage is the best approach and will produce a desirable result (A grade). The other says it is like planting grass among the trees and will still be very noticeable (he's had clients come back to him with poor results).
I can see the camouflage working with smaller mini-grafts but I am concerned if my plugs are too thick for them to be shielded adequately. However the prospect of major surgery with the linear excision and scarring is fairly terrifying given all I've been through, making the more conservative approach desirable. I can't help but think I'll be one of the 1% who has problems.
My overall goal is to restore a naturally looking appearance. It doesn't need to be perfect but I don't think I'd be happy if I can still see the plugs, or scars (i.e. noticeable as a transplant). I'm trying to determine if I can achieve a "very good" result (B+ / A- grade) with the camouflage as opposed to the major reconstructive surgery and higher risk with the linear excision that likely would produce an A+ result eventually.
Does anyone have knowledge of good repair results of large plugs leaving them alone and grafting around them? Or the opposite if this has produced unsatisfactory results?
Who are considered the best repair doctors in the States?
I feel completely confident that both doctors I consulted with are the best I can choose in my area. FWIW, I did email pictures to Dr. Konior and he recommended the linear excision of the hairline technique for the best result.
Both doctors agree I have a very good supply of donor hair. I even have fairly thick hair from the top of my head back through the crown. It is really just the front I need to deal with.
Thank you for your assistance in helping me sift through the information in making a decision. This will truly be life-altering in a good way, as I have had this "hanging over my head" for 20+ years.