After reading that, I'm now grateful that I chose a non-recommended surgeon (at least on here), but one based on the quality of output and how the surgeon works with his patients.
I think the idea of a website profiting off of incompetent surgeons, who are having enormously damaging effects on many people's lives, turns my stomach to the point of gastroseizure.
After reading this on the main website, unfortunately I doubt the concerns raised of 'recommended surgeons' will make a difference...
"To support the costs of operating and promoting our community the physician contributes a monthly fee to sponsor this community."
That tells me all I need to know about the recommended surgeons on this site.