Jump to content
Bill - Seemiller

Potential Coalition Membership for Dr. Timothy Carman

Recommended Posts

Dear Forum Members,

 

Since Dr. Timothy Carman was approved for recommendation in August of 2008, he has and continues to impress this community with examples of his ultra refined results and his passion and dedication to patient education. Coalition member Dr. William Reed who works with him has also become one of his biggest fans. Dr. Carman's expertise, wit, and likeable personality also shine brightly in answering dozens of hair loss questions monthly on our forum and popular Hair Loss Q&A Blog.

 

As the Old Russian Proverb declares 'trust but verify', we wanted solid evidence that Dr. Carman met the demanding criteria and standards set by this community before considering him for the Coalition of Independent Hair Restoration Physicians. To view the Coalition standards, click here. Thus, in addition to the impressive results Dr. Carman has posted on this community, Pat visited with and observed Dr. Carman in live surgery. He was very impressed by his passion and commitment to performing exclusive ultra refined hair transplantation. To see the highlights of Pat's visit, view 'Visit to Dr. Timothy Carman in La Jolla, CA'.

 

Dr. Carman has the experience, skill, and staff necessary to perform over 3000 follicular units in a single procedure and dense packing when appropriate for the patient.

 

Given Dr. Carman's experience and proven track record of producing ultra refined results, Pat and I firmly believe he should be considered for the Coalition.

 

To learn more about Dr Carman's experience, technique and philosophy, visit his Hair Transplant Network recommendation profile.

 

We welcome all input and comments regarding his potential inclusion.

 

View some of his recent patient photos below:

 

2893 Grafts with Dr. Carman - 7 Months

 

2757 Grafts with Dr. Carman - 7 Months

 

2176 Grafts with Dr. Carman - Results

 

2207 Grafts with Dr. Carman - 9 Months

 

3106 Grafts with Dr. Carman - 3.5 Months

 

2948 Grafts Post Op

 

3027 Grafts Post Op

 

Here are a few more of Dr. Carman's results for review.

 

2300 Grafts with Dr. Carman

 

2015 Grafts with Dr. Carman

 

1966 Grafts 1 Year Results

 

Several additional examples of Dr. Carman's ultra refined work can be found in the Results Posted by Leading Hair Transplant Clinics forum.

 

We look forward to your feedback.

 

Bill

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If the results posted are indicative of Dr. Carman's usual work, then he absolutely merits membership in the coalition.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

based on the results posted above that indicate Dr. Carman's usual work i say:

 

RECOMMENDED - maybe

COALITION - no

 

and here is why:

- most of the examples above are not even final results.

- documentation is not up to par with other COALITION presentations (no top down pics, dark lighting etc).

- not a single full grown 12-18 months result.

- none of the above examples are WOW examples.

 

take it for FWIW just my 2 cents.


------------------------------------------------------------

33dwk79.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have to agree w/ GQ. I know he must have plently of results. The couple I saw looked fine, but if he's done so many to merit coalition status, he must have more before and afters than this.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
but if he's done so many to merit coalition status, he must have more before and afters than this.

absolutely right Leeson!

we need at least 5-6 more fully grown examples as in 12 or preferably 18 moths to see for us to make a fair judgment and determination. plus they all need to be very detailed examples too with consistent lighting, top down shots, consistent background (blue or white), plenty of angles, sharp pics etc. i personally think that all of the coalition members should be required to post at least one top down pic for all of their examples. for "recommended" clinics, i think that we can give them a break and "look through the fingers" so to speak.

it is COALITION we are talking about here right?


------------------------------------------------------------

33dwk79.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Impressive results? I think you meant nice immediate post ops though Im sure he has final results he can show us

I also agree with GQ.

5 -10 nice 12 month results and I say yes seeing that the immed postops look good

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dear members,

 

Thank you for your feedback so far. In my opinion, based on all the evidence we've collected so far, Dr. Carman is doing work on par with leading surgeons in the field and meets our demanding standards for the Coalition. He's also garnered the support from Coalition member and well respected surgeon Dr. Bill Reed who works with him on a daily basis among other leading physicians.

 

Here are a few more of Dr. Carman's results for review.

 

2300 Grafts with Dr. Carman

 

2015 Grafts with Dr. Carman

 

Best wishes,

 

Bill

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been checking this board regularly for quite a long time, and I feel very good about Dr. Carman as part of the coalition. I've only seen and heard excellent things, and he seems to have the endorsement of some very well respected people on here.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It would be nice to see some more grown out results from Dr. Carmen. However, the results and immediate post-op pictures indicate he's performing top notch work. I would feel comfortable referring patients to him. So my vote is yes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Does he have any pics were he totally recreates someone's front, not just thickening of patients whom already have plenty of native hair? I mean, if someone like Business Teacher went to him, what could he expect? I know not the 7,000 (that's a rarity), but realistically.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dear Members,

 

Thanks to everyone who took the time to offer their valuable input on the potential Coalition membership for Dr. Carman.

 

Based on all the evidence we collected via private and public screening, patient member feedback, and input from other leading hair restoration physicians, we believe he's earned his rightful place in the highly esteemed Coalition of Independent Hair Restoration Physicians.

 

I know that some of you would have liked to have seen more grown out photos. However, we believe the examples above represent his usual first-rate ultra refined work. Dr. Carman has garnered the support of many leading surgeons who we've contacted by email including Coalition members Dr. Reed, Dr. Konior, Dr. Ron Shapiro, and many others.

 

I trust Dr. Carman will continue to impress our online patient community with impressive examples of his ultra refined work for years to come.

 

View Dr. Carman's Coalition Profile.

 

Best wishes,

 

Bill

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×